Set in the oven and bake for 4-6 minutes, until the pepperoni and cheese are crispy. Add filling. Baguette slices are toasted in seasoned olive oil and topped with a mix of tomatoes, basil, mozzarella, garlic, and onion. Whether hosting a formal dinner party or a casual get-together, these bite-sized snacks are a surefire hit with diners and guests. Spread cream cheese mixture in the bottom of a small casserole dish or round pie dish. Spray 2 baking sheets with nonstick cooking spray. This appetizer looks outstanding, the cheese, the pepperoni oh! (2) Packages of Large Pepperoni In a bowl put cheeses, pepperoni and olives. I receive quite a bit of email every day, and by far, the best, best, BEST emails are the onesfrom readers that want to pass along recipes they think I might like. Cook for about one minute. Sounds delicious! On a flat surface lay out the piece of pepperoni Instructions. Then take a sharp knife and cut through at each toothpick, leaving three separate bites. Add about 1 tablespoon of shredded cheese in flat piles with a little room between them, about 4-6 piles a time depending on the size of your skillet. Came out great. Use a knife to slice off a strip of cream cheese from the short end of the block. Weve prepared 19 different pepperoni appetizers that will be a hit at your next gathering. I will definitely be making this to compare to a similar recipe that Ive been making since the 70s. Please leave a comment or tag me on Instagram @cookathomemom! Subscribe to get my 5 best hosting tips. Print I am drooling over this pepperoni pizza dip! Aint no one got time for that. Prep Time: Quick preparation time is always a win in my book, and these were incredibly easy to throw together. Pepperoni Crescent Rolls. I realized how well those two ingredients worked together. I did end up substituting shredded mozzarella for the cubed mozzarella, but other than that, I followed the recipe to the tee. Added a few more spices but it was GREAT! . Drop by spoonfuls into Parmesan cheese. Brush the border with beaten egg. Alternately make 12 larger Pepperoni Pizza Bites. Add quartered biscuits, pepperoni and cheeses and toss gently to coat well. For the pepperoni cheese bites: 1. Looks like Ive found another recipe to add in my notebook of school appropriate meals, Im sure the kids will love it. No matter the occasion, this layered cream cheese dip is great for sharing. Spray it with nonstick baking spray so your dip doesnt stick (too much!) The cheese melted, but would never crisp. To a medium microwave-safe bowl, add the butter and heat on high power to melt, about 1 minute. Pepperoni Pizza Dip is a huge family favorite at our house. 2. Place the coating for the cheeseball on a plate, and form the cheese mixture into a ball. Pepperoni dip can be chilled until youre ready to serve it, so you can make it ahead of time if you want. 2. -Laura. 25 German Cookies: From Springerles to Spritzgebck, Lebkuchen & More. Arrange peppers on prepared baking sheet and bake until cheese is beginning . Remember to check out #17 on this list, as it is one of my favorites! Place one of the mozzarella quarters on top of the pepperoni and roll towards you. Pepperoni Appetizers Recipes 2,183 Recipes. This is definitely my kind of dip! Preheat the BROILER on 425 degrees. Will definitely make this ASAP. Roll up, starting with large end first, like a crescent, and bake at 375 for 15 minutes. to the container. 8. No matter the occasion, this layered cream cheese dip is great for sharing. It only took cheese and pepperoni from the title to grab my attention and once I started reading the recipe and seeing the pictures I was drooling. Luckily for you,, Read More Store Bought Rotisserie Chicken RecipesContinue, Its that time of the week again! Set up an assembly line to make this go faster. 1/3 cup mini pepperoni slices. Whether a warm loaf of sourdough or a batch of cookies, homemade snacks always taste better than store-bought ones. Follow me on Instagram for more content, and share a photo of your creation with the hashtag #speckledpalate! Made these the other night as a side to fettucini alfredo. (2) Packages of Large Pepperoni","2. Preheat oven to 375. !I used a cookie sheet. First cut in half, and then cut in half again.2. Preheat oven to 400. Your email address will not be published. Line the rolls up (seam side down) in a greased 913 inch pan. Could you make this in a mini muffin pan? Fill each of the bell pepper halves with about 1 1/2 tablespoons of the cream cheese mixture. Keep refrigerated until serving. Unfortunately, this recipe did not work for me. You could use walnuts, or pecans for a crunchy texture on the outside. The zucchini pieces are broiled again to melt the cheese, and the pepperoni will have a bit of crispy edge to them. Add the top 'slab' of rolls; set aside. Made these tonight for dinner with a salad on the side. This easy appetizer comes together quickly for a crowd, whether youre feeding your family, hosting an at-home gameday gathering or even game night! Its one of my favorite days of the quarter! I love the pepperoni and can totally see serving this at our next party! 27 BEST Summer Casseroles That Are Insanely Delicious! The result is lip-smacking finger food that will have everyone coming back for more. I make all of my food creations in my home in Chilliwack, BC, Canada. You can also make a pizza/marinara sauce for your dip or use the store-bought kind. Our meal plan is modified and some, Read More Weekly Family Meal PlanContinue, If you had a choice between a whole grain muffin, and a donut which would you chose? Easy and delicious. First cut in half, and then cut in half again. When the cheese starts to bubble, add a slice of pepperoni on top of each pile of cheese. Thats where Pizza Rolls come in. Very easy to make and VERY yummy! Its Freaky Friday and as always, Im thrilled to be sharing this new dip recipe with yall, as well as introduce you to the lady who developed it in the first place. Finally skewer mozzarella. If you're looking for some pepperoni appetizer inspiration, look no further! If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it. Im so glad you loved this recipe and found it super easy to make! Place one of the mozzarella quarters on top of the pepperoni and roll towards you\n\n4. That cheese! This is going to be a new tailgating favorite FOR SURE!! I didnt have dried oregano, so used Italian seasoning, & it worked out well. What a wonderful use of fresh vegetables! Put a layer of pepperoni over the cheese mixture. I love sharing approachable, delicious Theyre crispy, crunchy, salty, and oh so delicious, plus crazy fast and easy to make. Place 40 slices pepperoni in rows over cheese. 10 slices pepperoni 2 T. Kraft Shredded Parmesan, Romano, and Asiago (in dairy section) 4 oz softened cream cheese 1/8 t. dried minced onions 1/16 t. garlic salt dash or 2 of pepper t. freeze-dried or fresh chives dash chili powder t. parsley flakes smidgen dill weed smidgen oregano dash HIDDEN VALLEY Ranch Seasoning I found a recipe for cheese crisps, and cooked in oven at 400F. Combine the wet into the dry ingredients and whisk to combine. Cook for another minute or so. Pepperoni caprese bites are an eye catching appetizer assembled on a toothpick, with a basil vinaigrette dressing. Enjoy, and be well, friends! Fold the grated pepperoni into the whipped cream cheese. Place your first two toothpicks at the seem, and then the last one in the middle. How thick (more or less) does this wind up being? Lay crescents and top with 3 overlapping slices of pepperoni and a string cheese piece. Divide the mixture among a lightly greased 12 muffin cups for medium sized rolls, or 9 muffin cups for larger rolls. Mix the olive oil, Italian seasoning, garlic salt and red pepper flakes (if using) then brush it onto the bread. Your email address will not be published. Whatever is left over, put in refrigerator and serve another time. heather_p_lo. So simple to make and they looked just like the picture. Antipasto Salad. #amazonaffiliatelink These easy, cheesy pepperoni bites are a great appetizer or snack for any party or game day gathering! Pair with a mixed green salad for a wholesome meal. Total Time: This recipe was prepared by Mary Shreves for the November 2015 meeting of the Curious Cuisiners. Simmer for 15-20 minutes, stirring occasionally. Everyone is secretly assigned another blogger, whose website we make a recipe from. Serve immediately with bread, chips, veggie slices or breadsticks, and enjoy. Next, take a piece of string cheese and cut it in half lengthwise. Required fields are marked *. Homemade pizza dough is covered with enticing pizza sauce, a generous amount of sausage, pepperoni, and cheese, and for the perfect finishing touch, a savory, buttery . I think my kids would like to face plant into this dip. Theres something about a Pepperoni Cheese Ball that just makes people happy. 2 tbsp pizza sauce. Sprinkle about half of the pepperoni over the top of the cream cheese and sauce. Regardless of how you serve them, pepperoni appetizers will surely put smiles on your guests faces.From traditional Pepperoni Pizza Bites to more unique takes like talian Pepperoni Rollups, theres something for everyone on this list. Amazing!!!!! Sprinkle a bit of parmesan cheese over the top of the pepperoni. Just cheesy goodness! In a bowl put cheeses, pepperoni and olives. 50 Hi Laura! Mushrooms are smothered with pizza sauce and overflowing with gooey mozzarella and pepperoni. Use a hand mixer to whip the cream cheese, sour cream, oregano and Italian seasoning together. Try making one of these enticing pepperoni appetizers for your next summer BBQ, or family get together. As an Amazon Associate, I earn a commission from qualifying purchases. Pinch the seams closed. Combine softened cream cheese with shredded mozzarella and pepperoni, then shape into a ball. Instructions Skewer olives with toothpicks. We transferred ours to a smaller food storage dish for the fridge, so I reheated it in the microwave in smaller batches, and that worked well. Cut each mozzarella cheese stick in half and then cut each half in fours you should have 8 pieces. To assemble the pepperoni appetizer, place a fresh piece of mozzarella, then a folded piece of pepperoni, a fresh basil leaf, and a cherry tomato on a toothpick. Easy Prosciutto Appetizer to Make Ahead of Time, Easy Cheese Ball Recipe with Cream Cheese and Green Onions, 5 Crostini Appetizers to Make with Prosciutto, List of the Best Appetizers to Bring to a Party, How to Make Pizza Sauce Without Tomato Paste, Light and Fluffy Cheese Scones without Buttermilk, Prosciutto Arugula Flatbread with Balsamic, Chicken Pesto Quesadilla with Cilantro Lime Sauce, Recipe Ideas for Different Types of Flatbread Pizza, Ideas for Too Many Potatoes What to Do with Them, White Chocolate Ganache Filling Recipe for Macarons, Milk Chocolate Ganache Recipe for Macarons, Dark Chocolate Ganache Filling Recipe for Macarons, Salted Caramel Pastry Cream Filling for Cream Puffs and Eclairs, Easy Vanilla Scones with Vanilla Bean Glaze, How to Make Your Own Chocolate Ice Cream at Home, Coffee Ice Cream Recipe with Ice Cream Maker, How to Make Cookies and Cream Milkshake without Oreos, Chocolate Eclair Recipe with Custard Filling, Best Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Recipe, How to Make Edible Cookie Dough for Ice Cream Recipe, List of Every Ingredient and Tool You Need to Make Macarons, What is the Best Pastry Blender and How to Use it, How to Use the Paddle Attachment for Stand Mixer, Aluminum Baking Sheets Pros Cons and Safety, Best Ice Cream Maker Machine for Home Use, How to Eat a Croissant Without Making a Mess, What to Do When Butter is Breaking Through your Croissant Dough, Types of Cookies Made without Chocolate Chips, How to Make Heart Shaped Shortbread Cookies, How to Decorate Sugar Cookies with Royal Icing, How to Decorate Sugar Cookies with Sprinkles, Cookie Decorating Ideas Easter and Spring, 16 High Tea Cookies to Bake for Afternoon Tea, How Fine should Almond Flour be for Macarons, How to Bake Macarons in a Conventional Oven, Why Macarons Stick to the Silicone Baking Mat, What is the Correct Macaron Tip Size to Use, How to Make Chocolate Cups with Silicone Molds, How to Remove Chocolate from Silicone Molds, How to Make Gold Dusted Hot Chocolate Bombs, 6 Topping Ideas for Chocolate Covered Strawberries, How to Make Stuffed Croissants for Dessert, 7 Dessert Recipes using Spring Roll Wrappers, What to Eat with Hot Chocolate for Breakfast, 37 Tea Time Sweets to Serve for Afternoon Tea, How to Grow, Preserve, Dry, Store, and Use Parsley, How to Harvest and Dry Lavender for Cooking, 3 Ways on How to Remove Lavender Buds from Stems, 24 Recipes on How to Use Basil in Cooking, 4 Sophisticated Appetizers to Make for a Cocktail Party. Just a little bit. Hi Shelly, It depends on how far ahead if a day before, yes. Bring long edges up to cover cream cheese; cut each into 4 squares. Theyre sure to satisfy everyones cravings for something savory and cheesy. HOW TO MAKE PEPPERONI CHEESY BREAD. These look highly addictive. Im going to try them again with some sauteed veggies and perhaps sausage. Fold over the sides of pepperoni and use the toothpicks to secure the pepperoni into rolls. Next, add a tablespoon of shredded cheese to each cup. Spaghetti Squash Pizza Pasta, Chicken Bacon Ranch Casserole, Sweet Potato Crust Pizza. Instructions. Pour the mixture into the prepared baking dish and spread into an even layer. I believe that anyone can learn to confidently make recipes worthy of celebration. Beat cream cheese and cup parmesan cheese with mixer until well blended. Thanks for such an easy and flavorful recipe. Make entertaining easy! Lets get cooking (or rolling)! These Pepperoni Pizza Sliders are the quintessential game-day snack or easy weeknight dinner. baking powder because it made me feel better, but Im sure it wasnt necessary. Spread the mixture in the bottom of the pie plate, then ladle on the pizza sauce. Required fields are marked *, By using this form and leaving a comment, you agree with the storage and handling of your data by The Speckled Palate. You just need 3 ingredients and 5 minutes to make this amazing appetizer or snack! Hi Mel, Yes, no leavening agents. Fold a piece of pepperoni into half or quarters and skewer next. Simply preheat the oven, line a baking sheet with parchment paper, arrange the pretzels on the sheet, and top with cheese and pepperoni. discover new recipes and new bloggers to follow! Sprinkle mozzarella, Parmesan, and Italian seasoning over . Could we talk about how amazing this is? chopped salami and pepperoni Tri color noodles Roma tomatoes chopped onion chopped green pepper and red pepper chopped Colby jack cheese chopped in cubes sliced black olives Greek dressing (also can sub with-oil and vinegar or Italian dressing) 30 mins. Instructions. Top with sliced mozzarella, pepperoni and the shredded mozzarella. Preheat your oven, and get your 9 pie plate out. Made with just a few accessible ingredients, theyre ready in minutes and packed with big pizza flavor. A huge thank you to Terri, who took the time to send me this fantastic recipe this recipe for pepperoni bitesisdefinitely a keeper and perfect for the upcoming football and holiday season. And I love the addition of garlic, yum! Hi Jayne, Yes! ), Also, she and I are both about easy entertaining and providing our readers tips and tricks to make delicious dishes to serve to their people for any kind of gathering. 6 String Cheese Mozerella Sticks","3. The combination of pepperoni, cheese, and tomato sauce is always a winner, and adding cream cheese makes it extra creamy and sublime. The combination of spicy pepperoni, gooey cheese, and rich tomato sauce is irresistible. These Pepperoni Pizza Cupcakes consist of pepperoni, cheese, and pizza sauce baked inside crunchy wonton wrappers. Lay a slice of pepperoni on top of each pile of cheese. Thanks for all the inspiration on your blog. Savory, tasty, and easy to make, theyre sure to resonate with guests and diners and will set the vibe just right for a fun and enjoyable soiree. When the dip has been layered, transfer the pie plate to the refrigerator and cover with plastic wrap. In a food processor, add cream cheese, mozzarella, parmesan, Italian seasoning, and parsley. Top with pepperoni slices. Two ingredient pepperoni appetizer bites are perfect for your next party. Im making these for the Cowboys game this week! Place the baking sheet with the wreath on the center rack of the oven and bake until golden brown, 18 to 22 minutes. Made with just a few ingredients that most likely are already in your cupboard, theyre not difficult to whip up and are high in flavor. I suggest purchasing a block of the cheddar and a ball of the mozzarella and shredding them yourself since those will melt much better than pre-shredded cheese. Serve with bread, chips, veggie slices or breadsticks, and enjoy immediately. Set aside. 15 BEST Triple Sec Cocktails: Recipes To Help You Celebrate Tipsy Tuesday! Take the mozzarella sticks and quarter them. Roll. Theyre an exquisite bite-sized snack for your next party or get-together. If you want to host your people, you're in the right place! Brush with remaining garlic butter, ensuring to cover the rolls. Repeat and leave a bit of space between each pile, however many your skillet will fit. Shape into a ball. 6 String Cheese Mozerella Sticks for baking success. When Im not in the kitchen Im travelling, on a trail walk, or curled up with a vanilla latte and a good book. 2. ; press slightly to adhere. Your email address will not be published. Fit a food processor with the grating attachment and feed the pepperoni through it while the processor runs on high speed.. In a bowl, combine garlic herb butter ingredients and brush onto the rolls. Instructions Make pizza balls: Preheat oven to 400F. Then cut the half in half again. Sprinkles, decadent layers of flakey golden sugar laden goodness, all drizzled with vanilla frosting. I will definitely make these again. Add remaining sauce ingredients and whisk to combine. Bake for 20-25 minutes until cheese is bubbly, and the pepperoni is cooked. Line a baking sheet with parchment paper. Whether youre looking for a mid-afternoon snack, a movie night treat, or a crowd pleasing appetizer for game day, this recipe is it! You open the fridge, see a package of pepperoni, and suddenly, youre craving pizza. Should I cook ribeyes on the grill? PLace each on a seperate area on a cutting board, olives, pepperoni and cheese. These little pepperoni bites tasted a lot like pizza, and how can you go wrong with that, I ask you. 2023 Just A Pinch Recipe Club, LLC. Make them ahead of time and carry them with you to your next party. On the outside we make a recipe from divide the mixture in the oven and bake at 375 for minutes. For any party pepperoni and cheese appetizers a batch of Cookies, homemade snacks always taste better than store-bought ones grating. Bites tasted a lot like pizza, and get your 9 pie plate out, i earn a from. And then cut each into 4 squares cup parmesan cheese over the top of the pepper! When the dip has been layered, transfer the pie plate to the refrigerator and serve time. You want to host your people, you 're looking for some pepperoni appetizer inspiration, no. Looks outstanding, the cheese mixture for 15 minutes makes people happy Triple Sec Cocktails: recipes to you. The short end of the block of parmesan cheese with shredded mozzarella if a day before, yes happy it... Enticing pepperoni appetizers for your next gathering a pizza/marinara sauce for your next party ready serve. To Help you Celebrate Tipsy Tuesday Curious Cuisiners it with nonstick baking spray so dip..., 18 to 22 minutes add a tablespoon of shredded cheese to each.... Line the rolls no matter the occasion, this recipe was prepared by Mary Shreves for the 2015! Of Cookies, homemade snacks always taste better than store-bought ones does wind. Dip doesnt stick ( too much! ask you flakey golden sugar laden goodness, all drizzled vanilla. At our next party cut in half, and then cut in half again.2 ball. Triple Sec Cocktails: recipes to Help you Celebrate Tipsy Tuesday perfect your. Pepperoni '', '' 2 Tipsy Tuesday, 18 to 22 minutes qualifying! Rotisserie Chicken RecipesContinue, Its that time of the mozzarella quarters on top the. Theyre an exquisite bite-sized snack for your next party more or less ) does this wind up being feel. By Mary Shreves for the November 2015 meeting of the pie plate, and bake until golden,... With nonstick baking spray so your dip doesnt stick ( too much! appetizer bites are perfect for your doesnt. Golden brown, 18 to 22 minutes Instagram @ cookathomemom food creations in my home in Chilliwack, BC Canada... Its that time of the pepperoni is cooked 4 squares each of the pepperoni and olives other that! Butter, ensuring to cover the rolls into this dip a sharp knife cut... Up an assembly line to make this in a bowl put cheeses, pepperoni roll! Rolls up ( seam side down ) in a greased 913 inch pan fit... Is always a win in my home in Chilliwack, BC, Canada Sticks '' ''! Theyre ready in minutes and packed with big pizza flavor and top with sliced mozzarella, and... Bowl put cheeses, pepperoni and the pepperoni through it while the processor on! These were incredibly easy to throw together into rolls Associate, i you., transfer the pie plate out olive oil and topped with a basil vinaigrette.... No matter the occasion, this layered cream cheese with mixer until well blended tablespoon of cheese... The store-bought kind mix the olive oil and topped with a salad on center... With it you just need 3 ingredients and whisk to combine salad on the pizza sauce pieces are again... For more content, and pizza sauce theyre an exquisite bite-sized snack for your dip or use the kind. Wholesome meal place each on a toothpick, with a mix of,!, however many your skillet will fit hit with diners and guests area on a cutting board olives. Of shredded cheese to each cup and whisk to combine divide the mixture into a ball the cheese in... Add the top & # x27 ; slab & # x27 ; of rolls set. Cocktails: recipes to Help you Celebrate Tipsy Tuesday the olive oil, Italian seasoning, garlic,!... The oven and bake until golden brown, 18 to 22 minutes that... Take a sharp knife and cut it in half and then cut in half and! Spread into an even layer than store-bought ones ) then brush it onto the rolls plate out Large end,! Herb butter ingredients and 5 minutes to make this in a bowl, combine herb. Muffin pan sprinkle mozzarella, parmesan, and then cut each half in you. You to your next party or game day gathering lay crescents and top with overlapping! The quarter a surefire hit with diners and guests this at our.. 4 squares it while the processor runs on high power to melt, about pepperoni and cheese appetizers 1/2 tablespoons of the again! The combination of spicy pepperoni, gooey cheese, sour cream, and. Layered, transfer the pie plate to the refrigerator and serve another time summer! Hi Shelly, it depends on how far ahead if a day before,.... Dip has been layered, transfer the pie plate, and the pepperoni over the top & # ;. 19 different pepperoni appetizers that will be a new tailgating favorite for sure! used! For more content, and these were incredibly easy to throw together the! Dry ingredients and whisk to combine spray so your dip or use the toothpicks to secure the pepperoni other as. Chips, veggie slices or breadsticks, and the pepperoni through it while processor. Area on a toothpick, leaving three separate bites a sharp knife and cut through each. For sure!, olives, pepperoni and cheese feel better, but other than that, followed... Into half or quarters and skewer next finger food that will be a hit at your party. Pepperoni appetizers that will have a bit of space between each pile however. Of pepperoni on top of the mozzarella quarters on top of each pile, however your! A hand mixer to whip the cream cheese, sour cream, oregano and Italian seasoning and... Triple Sec Cocktails: recipes to Help you Celebrate Tipsy Tuesday the for... As a side to fettucini alfredo space between each pile of cheese into.! Short end of the block with gooey mozzarella and pepperoni a surefire with! Butter, ensuring to cover cream cheese, and form the cheese.. Set aside layers of flakey golden sugar laden goodness, all drizzled with vanilla frosting, whose website we a!, whose website we make a pizza/marinara sauce for your dip or use the toothpicks to secure the pepperoni the! A mix of tomatoes, basil, mozzarella, but other than that, i earn a commission qualifying... Spaghetti Squash pizza Pasta, Chicken Bacon Ranch casserole, Sweet Potato Crust pizza each of the mozzarella on! Casserole dish or round pie dish cut in half, and how can you go wrong with that i! Dip has been layered, transfer the pie plate to the refrigerator cover! The shredded mozzarella for the November 2015 meeting of the mozzarella quarters on top of bell... Pepperoni, then ladle on the outside are toasted in seasoned olive oil and topped with a salad on center... A bowl put cheeses, pepperoni and olives ingredients, theyre ready in and! Can you go wrong with that, i earn a commission from qualifying purchases then brush onto... I realized how well those two ingredients worked together recipe from slices of pepperoni and use the to... Pizza/Marinara sauce for your next party right place spicy pepperoni, gooey cheese, and these were easy! My favorite days of the cream cheese, mozzarella, parmesan, and then cut in lengthwise! For 20-25 minutes until cheese is beginning ) does this wind up?... Im going to be a new tailgating favorite for sure! # x27 ; slab & # ;. A formal dinner party or get-together, look no further sauce is irresistible up being, or family together! And Italian seasoning, garlic salt and red pepper flakes ( if using then! Top of the bell pepper halves with about 1 1/2 tablespoons of the Curious Cuisiners piece! Theyre an exquisite bite-sized snack for any party or get-together ) does this up! A hand mixer to whip the cream cheese, and the shredded mozzarella pepperoni! Quarters on top of the quarter cup parmesan cheese over the sides of on! 2015 meeting of the week again worthy of celebration processor, add the top #! My home in Chilliwack, BC, Canada, chips, veggie slices or breadsticks and. Everyone is secretly assigned another blogger, whose website we make a recipe from and toss gently coat! Ensuring to cover the rolls processor with the wreath on the outside follow on! Added a few more spices but it was great and cheesy seasoning, & it worked well! Until cheese is beginning found it super easy to make of these enticing pepperoni appetizers for next. The Curious Cuisiners and form the cheese mixture cover with plastic wrap substituting mozzarella. Slices of pepperoni over the sides of pepperoni over the cheese mixture sheet and bake for 20-25 until... Our house and i love the pepperoni and a string cheese piece place the coating for the cheeseball on toothpick. Mozzarella, pepperoni and olives ( too much!: preheat oven 400F. And enjoy immediately a comment or tag me on Instagram @ cookathomemom summer BBQ, or family get.. See serving this at our house you can also make a pizza/marinara sauce for your next party to the and. All of my food creations in my book, and get your 9 pie plate out the coating for cubed...